Disney Cruise vs Carnival Cruise: The Ultimate Comparison

Disney Cruise vs Carnival Cruise: The Ultimate Comparison

Disney Cruise vs Carnival Cruise: The Ultimate Comparison

This article is your complete guide to choosing between a Disney Cruise vs Carnival for your family vacation! Choosing which cruise line is better depends on the type of vacation you want to have. Both cruise lines offer unique experiences but cater to different types of travelers. Our comprehensive guide will help you weigh the differences between these two popular cruise lines. All to make sure you make the best choice for your family’s needs and budget!

We hope you find this post helpful! And if you are planning a Disney Cruise Line Vacation, check out our other FREE vacation planning tools. Our goal at The Park Prodigy has always been to help you save time on your next vacation and find the cheapest Disney Cruise Line Vacations!

Carnival vs Disney Cruise Line

When deciding between a Carnival vs Disney Cruise Line vacation, consider the type of experience you’re seeking. Choose Carnival for a budget-friendly, adult-centric cruise filled with vibrant nightlife and entertainment options. On the other hand, choosing a Disney Cruise offers a family-focused adventure where the magic of Disney meets the high seas! While Disney cruises are generally priced higher, they deliver unparalleled thematic experiences and attention to detail. Carnival cruises offer great value and fun for those prioritizing entertainment and relaxation.

Choose Carnival for a More Adult Cruise Experience

Carnival Cruise Line is known in the industry for its lively atmosphere. This makes it an excellent choice for adults seeking a vacation geared more toward entertainment and nightlife. Carnival offers a wide range of bars, clubs, and adult-focused activities.

Choose Disney for a Unique Cruise Line Experience

Disney Cruise Line offers an unparalleled experience for families. A vacation on a Disney Cruise immerses every passenger in the magical world of Disney while sailing on the high seas. Every guest can enjoy character meet-and-greets, themed entertainment, and family-friendly activities. Disney cruises create unforgettable memories for guests of all ages!

Related Post: Guide to a Disney Cruise for Adults

Disney Cruise Line vs Carnival – Ports of Call

Disney Cruise Line:

• Bahamas
• Western, Eastern, & Southern Caribbean
• Northern Europe
• Norwegian Fjords
• Mediterranean
• British Isles
• Bermuda
• Alaska
• Canada
• Mexican Riviera
• Baja
• Panama Canal
• Pacific Coast
• Transatlantic
• Hawaii
• South Pacific
• New Zealand & Australia
• Singapore – Sailing in 2025

Carnival Cruises:

• Caribbean
• Bahamas
• Mexico
• Europe
• Bermuda
• Alaska
• Canada
• New England
• Greenland
• Hawaii
• Panama Canal
• Transatlantic
• Transpacific
• Singapore
• Australia
• New Zeland
• Papua New Guinea
• South Pacific

Important to know: Both Carnival and Disney Cruise Line sail to popular destinations like the Caribbean, Bahamas, and Mexico, but Disney Cruise Line distinguishes itself with unique journeys to the Norwegian Fjords and the Mediterranean. These special itineraries offer families the opportunity to dive into diverse cultures and breathtaking landscapes, all under the signature service and magical experience Disney is renowned for. Disney’s excursions into Norway’s frozen frontiers and the Meditteranean’s historic cities provide memorable adventures with the convenience and attention to detail expected from Disney!

Related Post: Royal Caribbean vs Disney Cruise Line

Cabin Types

Disney Cruise Line:

• Standard/Deluxe Inside
• Deluxe/Family Oceanview
• Deluxe/Family Oceanview with Verandah
• Concierge Family Oceanview
• Concierge Family Oceanview with Verandah
• Concierge 1 & 2 Bedroom Suites with Verandah
• Concierge Royal Suite with Verandah
• Concierge 1 & 2 Stroy Royal Suites with Verandah
• Concierge Wish and Treasure Tower Suites

Carnival Cruises:

• Interior
• Oceanview
• Balcony
• Suite
• Family Harbor Stateroom & Suites
• Cloud 9 Spa Staterooms & Suites
• Havana Staterooms & Suites
• Terraza Staterooms

Important to know: Disney Cruise Line cabins are designed with families in mind. They offer spacious accommodations and the unique feature of split bathrooms! This is a game changer when you need multiple people to get ready at once. On the other hand, Carnival Cruise Line staterooms provide a wide array of cabin options that are more clean-cut in choice. From cost-effective interiors to opulent suites, there is something for every budget and preference.

Related Post: When is the Cheapest Time to Go on a Disney Cruise?

Carnival vs Disney – Pricing

Disney Cruise Line:

• Inside: $2,326
• Oceanview: $2,528
• Verandah: $2,824
• Concierge: $6,430

Carnival Cruises:

• Interior: $845.30
• Oceanview: $945.30
• Balcony: $1,165.30
• Suite: $1,665.30

All pricing above is for a 3-night sailing to the Bahamas on March 7th, 2025, from Port Canaveral, Florida. 

Important to know: When it comes to pricing, Carnival Cruise Line generally offers lower base fares, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious travelers. On the flip side, Disney Cruise Line prices reflect a strategy that, while higher, encompasses a wide range of premium amenities and unique experiences that aren’t available on other cruise lines. This contrast in pricing comes down to distinct brand philosophies: Carnival focuses on affordability and fun for all ages, whereas Disney emphasizes a more immersive family experience.

Related Post: How Many Ships Does Disney Have?

Amenities

Disney Cruise Line:

• Live Shows & Entertainment
• Disney Character Experiences
• Family Friendly Activities
• Fireworks at Sea
• Deck Parties
• Movie Theaters
• Rotational Main Dining
• Adult-Exclusive Dining
• Youth Clubs
• Nightclubs & Lounges
• Family Venues
• Pools & Water Slides
• Spa & Salon Services
• Shopping
• Sports & Fitness Centers
• AquaMouse – A Disney Attraction at Sea – available only on the Wish & Treasure

Carnival Cruises:

• Live Shows & Entertainment
• Spa & Salon Services
• Youth Clubs
• Nightclubs & Lounges
• Deck Parties
• Pools & Water Slides
• Family Venues
• Shopping
• Sports & Fitness Center
• Dive-in Moveis

Important to know: Both Carnival and Disney Cruise Line impress guests with amenities like pools, spas, fitness centers, and kids’ play areas, but Disney takes entertainment to another level. Offering Broadway-quality shows, vibrant deck parties, and spectacular fireworks at sea, Disney provides a unique entertainment experience that stands out in the cruise industry.

Related Post: How Much Does a Disney Cruise Cost Per Person?

Inclusions – Disney vs Carnival Cruise

Disney Cruise Line:

• Your Stateroom
• Entertainment
• Variety of Dining Options
• 24-hour Room Service
• Nightclubs & Lounges
• Youth Clubs
• Pools & Recreation
• Private Island
• Character Meet & Greets

Carnival Cruises:

• Your Stateroom
• Entertainment
• Variety of Dining Options
• Nightclubs & Lounges
• Youth Clubs
• Pools & Recreation
• Private Island
• Carnival Players Club

Important to know: Disney Cruise Line’s pricing strategy offers families exceptional value by including perks like complimentary soft drinks at meals and 24-hour room service in their fares! Making it a cost-effective choice for a family vacation. On the other hand, Carnival Cruise Line adopts an a la carte pricing model, allowing guests to personalize their experience by paying extra for specific amenities and activities. This approach provides flexibility, catering to those who prefer to customize their cruise experience according to their preferences and budget.

Related Post: Every Disney Cruise Ship from the Newest to Oldest

Add-On Packages

Disney Cruise Line:

• Pre-Pay Gratuities
• Ground Transportation
• Refillable Beer Mug
• In-Room Gifts
• Spa & Salon Services
• Internet Access (unless staying in a Concierge-level stateroom)
• Port-Adventures
• Vacation Protection

Carnival Cruises:

• Pre-Pay Gratuities
• Beer, Wine, Spirit, & Sodas
• Ground Transportation
• In-Room Gifts
• Spa & Salon Services
• Internet Access
• Port-Adventures
• Vacation Protection
• Casinos

Important to know: Disney and Carnival both enhance the cruising experience with optional add-on packages, including alcohol, excursions, and internet access, allowing guests to tailor their vacation to their specific desires. These add-ons provide the opportunity for families to budget more effectively and personalize their journey at sea. By considering these packages, families can ensure they’re getting the most value out of their cruise. No matter whether they’re looking to enjoy unlimited beverages, explore new destinations through excursions, or stay connected with friends and family back home through internet access.

Related Post: Every Disney Cruise Ship Ranked

Dining Options – DCL vs Carnival

Disney Cruise Line:

• 4 Main Dining Options
• 1 Buffet
• 2 Sweet Shops
• 3+ All Day Eateries
• 4 Additional Fee Dining Options

Carnival Cruises:

• 1 Main Dining Room
• 1 Sweet Shop
• 1 Buffet
• 4 All Day Eateries
• 16 Included Timed Eateries
• 19 Additional Fee Dining Options

Important to know: On both Disney and Carnival cruises, dining emerges as a key highlight. Both cruise lines offer everything from laid-back buffets to upscale fine dining experiences. Disney Cruise Line stands out with its innovative rotational dining system, where guests rotate through uniquely themed restaurants while retaining the same dedicated serving team. Meanwhile, Carnival boasts a wide variety of dining choices, including specialty restaurants and exclusive collaborations with celebrity chefs, catering to a broad spectrum of tastes and preferences, ensuring that every meal is an adventure in itself.

Related Post: Complete List of Disney Cruise Line Characters

Included Entertainment

Disney Cruise Line:

• Broadway-quality Shows
• Nightclubs & Lounges
• Disney Character Greetings
• Deck Parties
• Fireworks at Sea
• Themed Cruises
• Themed Nights
• Themed Dining

Carnival Cruises:

• Family Feud Live
• Playlist Productions Shows
• Comedy Club
• Dive-In Movies
• Karaoke
• Live Music
• Nightclubs
• Deck Parties

Important to know: Disney cruises excel in providing unparalleled entertainment, featuring Broadway-quality live shows, movie theaters screening the newest Disney films, and lively deck parties that captivate guests of all ages. Similarly, Carnival matches up with its own impressive lineup of entertainment options, from live music and comedy shows to specially-themed nights that cater to diverse interests. Both cruise lines ensure a vibrant and engaging atmosphere, making every moment onboard a memorable one, whether you’re immersed in the magic of Disney or enjoying Carnival’s wide-ranging entertainment offerings.

Related Post: Your Complete Guide to Disney Christmas Cruises

Private Islands

Disney Cruise Line:

• Castaway Cay – Bahamas
• Lighthouse Point – Bahamas – opening Summer 2024

Carnival Cruises:

• Amber Cay – Dominican Republic
• Grand Turk – Turks and Caicos
• Half Moon Cay – Bahamas
• Princess Cay – Bahamas
• Mahogany Bay – Honduras

Important to know: Both Disney and Carnival own private islands in the Bahamas, offering exclusive beach days with activities and amenities. Disney’s Castaway Cay is especially popular for its family-friendly design and Disney touches. While we love Castaway Cay, the amount of private islands available on a Carnival Cruise is undeniably a win for Carnival! No matter where you’re sailing, chances are you will be able to enjoy an island all to yourself.

Related Post: Check out Disney’s Adult-Only Beach!

Disney Cruise vs Carnival Kid’s Clubs

Disney Cruise Line:

• Oceaneer Club – Ages 3 – 12
• Oceaneer Lab – Ages 3 – 12
• Edge – Ages 11 – 14
• Vibe – Ages 14-17
• “It’s a Small World” Nursery – Ages 6 months – 3 years

Carnival Cruises:

• Camp Ocean – Ages 2 – 11
• Space Cruisers – Ages 2 – 11
• Club 02 – Ages 15 – 17
• Circle “C” – Agest 12 – 14
• Turtles – Ages 6 months – 1 year

Important to know: For families both Disney and Carnival shine in this department. Disney’s kid’s clubs captivate with their enchanting themes and are overseen by counselors trained specifically to engage young imaginations. Carnival, on the other hand, impresses with its diverse array of activities designed to entertain and include children of all ages. However, we still have to say that Disney Cruise Line is the standout when it comes to catering the cruise for little ones!

Related Post: How to Book a Disney Cruise at a Discounted Rate

Themed Cruises

Disney Cruise Line:

• Pixar Day at Sea
• Marvel Day at Sea
• Halloween on the High Seas
• Very Merrytime Cruises

Carnival Cruises:

• Halloween Cruise with Carnival
• Carnival’s “Fun Ship” Cruises

Important to know: Disney Cruise Line specializes in themed cruises, like Halloween on the High Seas, providing an immersive experience with character encounters, special shows, and activities that deeply engage fans, making Disney an ideal choice for those seeking themed adventures at sea. On the other hand, Carnival does have a Halloween and Christmas cruise, but beyond that, there aren’t any other special sailings. There are themed nights onboard most cruises but not a fully themed cruise.

Related Post: All of Disney’s Themed Cruises

Which is Better: Disney Cruise Line or Carnival Cruise

While we think no cruise line can compare to a Disney Cruise, deciding if Disney Cruise Line or Carnival Cruise is the better cruise line ultimately hinges on what you value most in a vacation. If you’re looking for the unparalleled magic and storytelling that Disney is famous for, it is ideal for families with young children or Disney enthusiasts. Carnival Cruise, however, stands out for its budget-friendly options, vibrant nightlife, and diverse entertainment. This cruise line appeals mostly to adults seeking a fun, cost-effective getaway.

Is Carnival or Disney Cheaper?

While Carnival typically offers lower base prices, the inclusive pricing and magical extras of Disney Cruise Line deliver great value, especially for families seeking enchanting experiences. Deciding between Disney and Carnival boils down to your cruise priorities: the spellbinding charm of Disney or Carnival’s vibrant, budget-friendly fun.

Related Post: What is the Best Disney Cruise Ship?

Disney Cruise vs Carnival FAQ

Q: What age group is best suited for Disney Cruise Line?

A: Disney Cruise Line is designed with families in mind, making it ideal for children and Disney enthusiasts of all ages. The line specializes in creating magical experiences that cater specifically to families with young children and teens.

Q: Can adults enjoy a Carnival Cruise without children?

A: Absolutely. Carnival Cruise is known for its lively atmosphere and adult-oriented entertainment, including nightlife, bars, and adult-only areas, making it a great option for adults traveling without children.

Q: Are there any exclusive destinations offered by Disney Cruise Line?

A: Yes, Disney Cruise Line offers unique itineraries such as Alaska and European cruises, alongside their private island, Castaway Cay, which is designed to embody the Disney magic with activities and amenities for the whole family.

Q: How does the dining experience compare between Disney and Carnival?

A: Disney Cruise Line features rotational dining, allowing guests to experience various themed restaurants with the same serving staff, while Carnival offers a wide range of dining options, including specialty restaurants and partnerships with celebrity chefs.

Q: What type of entertainment can be expected on Carnival Cruises?

A: Carnival Cruises provides a variety of entertainment options suited for all ages, including live music, comedy shows, themed nights, and more, ensuring that there’s something for everyone to enjoy during their cruise.

When is The Best Time to Embark on a Disney Cruise?

Our Disney World Crowd Calendar is the best tool to help you get the most out of your time at sea. This is simply because most guests who embark on a Disney Cruise pair their sea vacation with a land one in the parks. That’s why we break down park crowds, park hours of operation, ticket prices, and average temperature to help you better book your Disney Cruise Line Vacation. We also break down the best time to go on a Disney Cruise based on specific times of the year and special events.

Are You Ready to Plan Your Next Disney Cruise Trip?

Are you planning a trip to Walt Disney World? Be sure to speak with a Disney World Travel Agent for the most recent deals and promotions. The Park Prodigy will provide a Free Quote for all Disney Cruise Vacation Packages. The Park Prodigy can also help you save up to $20 per ticket when purchasing your Walt Disney World Tickets, and we offer promotional discounts for special events such as Mickey’s Not So Scary Halloween Party Tickets and Mickey’s Very Merry Christmas Party Tickets.

Don’t forget to check out our wonderful friends over at Theme Park Today, as well!